415-456-6697

Resilience Re-Visited

Resilience Re-Visited

Resilience Re-Visited

I’m teaching Cultivating a Resilience Mindset at the Psychotherapy Networker Symposium this week. Tenth consecutive year, including online during the worst of the pandemic. My first in-person workshop since the pandemic shutdown two years ago. My final time teaching at the Symposium ever, retiring July 1, 2022. In fact, it was Michael Gelb, whom I met at the Symposium many years ago, who gave me the phrase “from retirement to Renaissance.” 

I’m taking off some of the pressure by re-posting one of my first e-newsletters ever: Resilience Re-Visited. Back in the day, every newsletter included reflections, poetry and quotes to inspire, stories to learn from, exercises to practice, and resources of books and websites. Some of which wound up in Bouncing Back: Rewiring Your Brain for Maximum Resilience and Well-Being.

Our attention spans have diminished; my posts became more concise, more practical.  May this revisit still be instructive and inspiring. 

………………..

RESILIENCE RE-VISITED 

The morning I sent out last month’s e-newsletter, Shifting Perspectives Leads to Resilience, a close friend’s sister-in-law was having surgery for breast cancer, another friend was in the ER for a flare up of back pain, and a client’s house burned down. By the end of the week, a different client’s husband had been diagnosed with Lou Gehrig’s disease, and a colleague’s husband had drowned in a boating accident.

Powerful reminders: none of us are immune from suffering, loss or sorrow in this life.  None of us are immune to being asked to cope with what we never asked for, with what we deeply, deeply do not want.

This month’s newsletter explores the deeper roots of resilience in the face of trauma and loss – the importance of compassion, connection and community to stabilize us when the ground is pulled out from underneath.  We learn three stages of drawing on the resilience of others to re-right ourselves when our own resilience seems nowhere to be found.

REFLECTIONS

COMPASSIONATE CONNECTION DEEPENS RESILIENCE

Resilience – the capacity to recover from trauma and respond flexibly to misfortune and change – is greatly enhanced when we feel safely held in the hearts and minds of people close to us, or even in the sympathetic understanding of people in the same boat as us.

The nationwide use of support groups as adjunctive medical treatment for life threatening illnesses was launched when researchers at Stanford University found that, for women patients in the terminal stages of breast cancer, participating in a weekly support group extended their lives 12-18 months and significantly improved the quality of their lives during that time.  

In 2005 neuroscientists discovered that women holding their husband’s hands during a pain study not only did not experience the pain levels that women holding no one’s hand or a stranger’s hand experienced; they experienced a positive sense of pleasure rather than pain because of the secure attachment with their husbands during the procedure.

In our own lives, we rely on compassionate connection from partners, friends, family, and on the teaching examples of others, to help pull us through our own suffering and overwhelm to find our capacities for resilient coping again.  In my experience, this recovery of resilience happens in three stages.

1. REFUGE

Refuge simply means a safe, supportive place to hang out when we are fragile or discombobulated.  A safe place to cry until we’re done crying, or rant until we’re done ranting.  We may seek refuge among good friends who know us well, as the song below suggests. People we trust won’t judge or disdain us when we become emotionally unglued or our thinking becomes unhinged.  People who can simply sit and be with us until we re-group and are ready to face the world again.

FRIENDS

We live out our lives, they say, all alone,

From the day we arrive til it’s time to go home.

Well, it’s only just lately I’ve come to accept

The grace I’ve been given in the company I’ve kept.

As my body grows wider, my hair it grows thin.

The seasons pass quicker, my head starts to spin.

Well, I’ve learned to take refuge in the sight of a friend.

The moment we meet up, my heart says amen.

So listen up friends, I’ll tell you what’s true.

Of all things in life, the best one to do

Is to always be happy, and never to fear.

But if you can’t do that, make sure good friends are near.

– Kevin Carr

*****

Sometimes we find refuge among people who don’t know us at all, but who can comfort and shelter us in we’re-all-in-the-same-boat human sympathy.

Years ago my dad had a stroke big enough to land him in the hospital or a few days, and a skilled nursing facility after that.  While there, my dad became suicidal.  The staff called me at 5:30am to come pick him up.  In his confused mental state, even at the age of 80, he had managed to climb out onto a second story deck overlooking the courtyard and was threatening to jump.

When I arrived at the nursing facility, I managed to get my dad into my car to take him home.  But I was completely bewildered about what to do in the next few days, weeks, months.  Before I could get in the car myself, I burst into tears.  I collapsed right there on the curb of the parking lot, and just sobbed and sobbed and sobbed.  All the grief and fear and confusion and anguish just welling up and spilling over.  The nurse who had discharged my dad saw me out the window; she came out of the building and gently took my hand as she sat with me on the curb.  For the next 30 minutes, she never said a word. She just held my hand with one hand; her other hand gently stroking my back.  She stayed present with me as I cried out wave after wave of grief, fear, confusion, anguish.

Eventually the waves of tears subsided.  I looked up into her eyes and saw simply someone seeing me, seeing my pain, someone caring for me, caring for my pain, caring for all the pain of all the family members who had ever gone through what I was going through, all the pain of the human condition. No matter what the next moment brought, in that moment I knew my struggle was completely seen, understood, accepted.  The nurse’s unspoken empathy allowed me to normalize my experience and re-group.

*****

Finding refuge can work in imagination as well in person.  We can learn to use our visualizations to remember safe places or safe people to take refuge in whenever we need to re-center ourselves in a stressing moment.  No matter what crises I have to field during the day – possibly suicidal patients or spouses outraged at learning of an affair, simply thinking about my partner being happy to see me at the end of the day – thinking about my cats being happy to see me at the end of the day! – makes everything manageable.

[We learn how to use guided visualization to create inner resources of compassionate connection in Exercises to Practice below.

Finding refuge in compassionate connection with others calms down our nervous systems, “re-settles the molecules” as my friend Phyllis would say.  And stabilizes us for stage 2 in deepening resilience.

2. REMINDERS

By reminders of how to be resilient, I don’t mean reassurances that conditions “out there” will get better soon – the job will come through or the chemo will knock back the cancer or someone else will come along soon to make you happy – because those external conditions may not manifest the way we want or when we want.

Rather, friends remind us of, and share their faith in, our own innate goodness, our own innate courage and resilience.  They remind us that we are “naturally creative, resourceful and whole” when we have lost any sense of that ever being true or that it could ever be true again.

The Way It Is

There’s a thread you follow.  It goes among

things that change.  But it doesn’t change.

People wonder about what you are pursuing.

You have to explain about the thread.

But it is hard for others to see.

While you hold it you can’t get lost.

Tragedies happen; people get hurt

or die; and you suffer and get old.

Nothing you do can stop time’s unfolding.

You don’t ever let go of the thread.

– William Stafford, The Way It Is

Friends help us remember and believe again in the worth of our own thread and our capacities, sometimes growing in new ways through the current crisis, to hang on to it.

[We learn how to brainstorm ways we have resiliently held on to the thread in the past to support us now in Exercises to Practice below.]

3. RE-FRAMING

One of my favorite Calvin and Hobbes cartoons is an inspiring moment when Calvin trips and falls down the stairs, lands in a heap at the bottom, dazed and confused  Then he stands himself up again, throws his arms up in the air as though welcoming applause and says, “Ta da!”

Any time we turn a mis-step into a mastery, we are deepening our resilience.  Any time we can see the AFGO – Another Fricking Growth Opportunity – in what appears to be a disastrous turn of events, we are deepening our resilience.  Any time we can shift our perception of a potential catastrophe to a larger, wise understanding of the big picture, we are deepening our resilience.

The Chinese written character for crisis is two characters together: danger and opportunity.  Any time we can see the opportunity in a sudden loss or potential crisis, seeing the potential danger clearly, too, of course,  as Adele did in Stories to Learn From below, we are deepening our resilience.

Buddhist meditation teacher Sylvia Boorstein teaches this re-frame, “May I meet this moment fully; may I meet it as a friend.”  

It is often our friends, partners, mentors, who remind us to look for the life lessons in every moment of our life’s journey, deepening our capacities to cope with the next overwhelming event, and the next and the next.

This month I want to use a familiar teaching story to further deepen our understanding of re-framing as a tool to deepen our resilience.

A young mother in a small village was completely bereft at the sudden death of her 8 year old son.  She desperately ran through the village looking for anyone who could bring him back to life.  A neighbor directed her to a monk living on the outskirts of the village who reassured her that, indeed, he could bring her son back to life if she  brought him a mustard seed from any house in the village that had never known death.

Excitedly, the woman ran from door to door with her request for a mustard seed.  But at each house she heard, “No, sorry, our uncle died last week.” Or  “No, sorry, my wife died last year.”  Finally the woman came to realize that her household was no different than any other household in the village.  Every person in the village had suffered the loss of someone near and dear to them.  Pain and suffering are universal to being human.  

When we can re-frame our pain as the pain of being human, feel the pain fully but not take it personally, then we come into the larger perspective, the larger awareness, that pain and suffering are an inevitable part of human existence. We realize we are not the only ones who have to cope with what we never asked for and never wanted.  As real and overwhelming as our pain might be, we can move beyond “Why me?” to “What now?” We face the unknown, as everyone must, from our own inner wisdom of acceptance and compassion. Indeed, our own suffering becomes the gateway to humbly become a compassionate refuge for others.  

POETRY AND QUOTES TO INSPIRE

“It is in the shelter of each other that the people live.”  Irish blessing, thanks to
– Mary Pipher

****

“The roots of resilience are to be found in the felt sense of existing in the heart and mind of an empathic, attuned, self-possessed other.” 

– Diana Fosha

****

OUT OF A GREAT NEED

Out of a great need

We are all holding hands

And climbing.

Not loving is a letting go.

Listen, 

The terrain around here

Is far too dangerous

For that.

– Hafiz,  The Gift, translated by Daniel Ladinsky

****

BEANNACHT  (“Blessing”)

On the day when
the weight deadens
on your shoulders
and you stumble,
may the clay dance
to balance you. 

And when your eyes
freeze behind
the grey window
and the ghost of loss
gets in to you,
may a flock of colours,
indigo, red, green,
and azure blue
come to awaken in you
a meadow of delight. 

When the canvas frays
in the currach of thought
and a stain of ocean
blackens beneath you,
may there come across the waters
a path of yellow moonlight
to bring you safely home. 

May the nourishment of the earth be yours,
may the clarity of light be yours,
may the fluency of the ocean be yours,
may the protection of the ancestors be yours.
And so may a slow
wind work these words
of love around you,
an invisible cloak
to mind your life.

– John O’Donohue, Echoes of Memory

STORIES TO LEARN FROM

This month’s story on resilience is from How We Choose to Be Happy by Rick Foster and Greg Hicks, a book I enthusiastically recommend in the Resources of Books and Websites section below.  It’s an inspiring story that illustrates the three stages of refuge, reminders, and re-framing that we explore in Reflections.

Within a two year period, Adele’s parents died, skyrocketing rents forced her business into bankruptcy, her husband left her for another woman, her house burned to the ground in the Oakland hills fire, and her beloved dog died.

“As my initial shock began to clear, a feeling that I wanted to live outweighed all of my thoughts about death.  I began to see there was hope among the ashes.  There was one big opportunity – I had a clean slate.  I wanted to feel whole.  I was sure that I wanted to embrace everything in life – the good and the bad.  As long as I had to start over and create a whole new life, I was going to create a happy one.”

Adele cried a lot.  When she felt empty, she meditated.  When she felt unsure, she called a friend to talk about what she was going through.  She joined a support group for women.  She poured out her heart in un-mailed letters to her mom, dad, and ex-husband.  And, stripped down to essentials, to her real self, she began building a more authentic life for herself.

Adele re-framed losing every external support she had as an opportunity to draw on her own resilient resources within.  “What I never had before was self-knowledge.  Now, I know myself.  I know my limits, my emotional range, my loves.  And I know I can build a life around those things.  What I have now [thriving catering business, a serene “tree house” home in the Berkeley hills, warm, intimate friendships) is a life that reflects the real me!”

EXERCISES TO PRACTICE

REFUGE

Find a place and time where you can sit quietly for a few moments, safe from any possible interruption.  Settle into a relaxed posture; allow your eyes to gently close.  Bring your awareness to your breath flowing gently in and out.

When you’re ready, think of someone who has shown faith in you in the past.  This could be a family member, close friend, teacher, coach, even a beloved pet who loves and trusts you.  Imagine them sitting with you in this moment.  Sense the comfort of sitting with them; notice where you feel that comfort in your body.  You may imagine two or three more people sitting with you, if you like.  Sense any calm or peacefulness or ease sitting in this imaginary circle of refuge.  Stay here in your imagination as long as you like.

Practice calling upon this circle of refuge five or six times a day as you go about your week until remembering this circle becomes a helpful habit.  Be sure you actually feel the comfort in your body as you evoke the circle in your mind.  Rehearsing creates the pathways in your brain that will make it more likely you will actually remember to call up this circle of refuge in moments of stress or overwhelm, and that you will actually feel soothed when you do.  

REMINDERS

Sift through memories of past times when you have had to cope with loss or trauma.  Find 3-5 times where you have actually coped pretty well.  Share the memories of these times with friends in your life now, so they can help you remember your capacities to cope when you temporarily forget or discount them yourself.

RE-FRAMING

Recall at least three times in your life where you have learned something useful from a distressing experience or crisis.  Recall what lessons you learned, and also how your learned them.  Talking it over later with a friend?  A friend or therapist talking it over with you?  Thinking things through on your own?  Journaling?

For any of those times, see if it’s possible to imagine other people coping with the same circumstances, reframing your pain as the pain of human experience.  Your fear as the fear.  See if there’s at least one example where your experience seems genuinely universal, shared by others.  Draw on the truth of that universally shared vulnerability – and resilience – to sustain you.

BOOKS AND WEBSITES

This month’s recommended reading:

How We Choose to Be Happy by Rick Foster and Greg Hicks. Penguin Books, 1999.

Resilience is a major theme in this empowering distillation of qualities common to people who have come to genuine inner peace and happiness in their lives.  The authors’ examples of resilience, drawn from hundreds of person to person interviews, teach us to deepen our own resilience through compassion, connection, and choice.

Hannah’s Gift: Lessons from a Life Fully Lived by Maria Housden.  Bantam Books, 2002.

The moving story of a young girl’s battle with leukemia, and the lessons learned by her family of the transformative and resilient power of love.

Wisdom & inspiration direct to your inbox